Sight and hearing:
This article had the least to say but the most to understand. And the reason I chose to write about this topic is because I am heavily inspired by 2 Bollywood movies, called Sairat and A Wednesday. In a nutshell, the final scenes of both movies were similar yet poles apart, in the sense that, one used only narration (sound) with a static picture and the other only used video with no sound. Its interesting how both convey the same feeling in totally opposite way. It’s the director’s and cinematographer’s skills that just by 1 element, they put such deep effect on audience’s mind.
It is truly presented in the article that both- sound and Image can side by side but for improvisation, when sound can do the job, there is no need of the video to be played. It stills works the best if we pause the video on a certain symbolic point and let the audio do the magic and vice-versa.
The most interesting guidelines given in the article are-
When the eye is entirely won, giving nothing or almost nothing to the ear. And when a sound can replace an image, cut the image or neutralize it.
In my personal opinion, sound can do the wonders that probably an image can never do. It’s all because ears go more inwards while eyes are always the surface or just outwards. This phenomenon leaves in deep thoughts and makes me be more creative while directing a media.
If you see the history, there are great examples of both elements in their own worlds and eras. Earlier, we used to have either newspapers or magazines which used only eyes to express thoughts or radios where, only ears do the job. Both had brilliant ways to educate the audience. For example, when reporting an accident, the audience understands the whole scenario only by looking at the image shown on the papers and reading the news. It is as good as witnessing what happened on-spot. Similarly, during football or cricket commentary, radio provides the best service for people to listen to whatever is happening in the field by just listening to radio.
It’s amazing how hearing and sight play an important role and how they are never dependent on each other. It is hence correctly said that, Image and sound must not support each other, but must work each in turn through ‘a sort of relay’.